Final count: 29 from my own list.
As is inevitable with this kind of aggregated voting, the list mostly tends to be the iconic, canonical titles with a handful of "modern classics". I don't see this as a disappointment... we're an eclectic bunch with widely varying tastes so of course the consensus is mainly going to occur on those films that everybody loves. Still, I can't help wishing there were a few more surprises.
It's really seeing your individual lists that makes this endeavor worthwhile, the aggregated list is just a bonus.
Thanks to Wilson and all the participants for the hard work you put into this.