Matty was great. He brought personality and energy to the show, and I miss him. Matty and Adam's version of Filmspotting had an entertainment value that is sometimes missing from the latest version of the show. With Josh and Adam there is a greater level of expertise that occasionally results in giving the impression of two art critics speaking in some rarefied air that is kind of hard to reach.
The problem with my characterizations above is that they are not all-or-nothing scenarios. Matty had a strong knowledge of film and an expertise that certainly surpassed mine and I would guess many other lay people's, and Josh and Adam do have fun, and the show is often entertaining. They are just two very distinctly different tones, and I would be hard-pressed to say which I like better.