Pure gut on these. Multiple films on my top 100 gets you an automatic 10, other tens are based on feeling and vibe. Don't really care about bad movies unless they're really bad (looking at you, George Lucas).
Group 1
Allen, Woody - 8
Almodovar, Pedro - 7
Brooks, James L. - 6
Burton, Tim - 7
Cameron, James - 7
Carpenter, John - 9
Coen, Joel and Ethan - 10
Coppola, Francis Ford - 9
Craven, Wes - 8
Cronenberg, David - 9
De Palma, Brian - 8
Demme, Jonathan - 8
Donner, Richard - 7
Eastwood, Clint - 8
Forman, Milos - 7
Friedkin, William - 9
Godard, Jean-Luc - 8
Herzog, Werner - 8
Howard, Ron - 8
Jackson, Peter - 8
Jarmusch, Jim - 8
Landis, John - 8
Lee, Ang - 8
Lee, Spike - 8
Leigh, Mike - 9
Lucas, George - 3
Lynch, David - 8
Malick, Terrence - 10
Mann, Michael - 8
Miyazaki, Hayao - 10
Polanski, Roman - 10
Reitman, Ivan - 8
Romero, George - 8
Scorsese, Martin - 9
Scott, Ridley - 9
Soderbergh, Steven - 10
Spielberg, Steven - 10
Stone, Oliver - 7
Tarantino, Quentin - 9
Verhoeven, Paul - 9
Von Trier, Lars - 9
Weir, Peter - 8
Wong, Kar-Wai -
Zemeckis, Robert - 7