Catching up with this after episodes were made available on Hulu. We planned on checking out the pilot earlier in the week and ended up watching seven episodes that night. Five days later and we've plowed through to the third (and final) season.
I love Damon Wayans Jr. on New Girl, and here he's given even more material to work with. He and Eliza Coupe are easily my favorites and they usually produce at least one laugh out loud moment every episode. They're so great together.
Casey Wilson and Adam Pally are also very funny. The weak links are Elisha Cuthbert and Zachary Knighton as the central couple. They both have a limited range and that range occupies the most basic sitcom humor, and even then it's very hit and miss.
That said, the show is exceptionally well written. Building gags and often providing huge payoffs to running jokes. It's so great.
Of course it was cancelled.