Some great suggestions here! I haven't got a library to refer to, but Bob Dylan's songbook seems to be enough this time:
- I Threw It All Away (Nashville Skyline, 1969)
- I Shall Be Released (given to The Band, on their Music From Big Pink (1968) album)
- I And I (Infiedels, 1983)
- I Want You (Blonde On Blonde, 1966)
- I Feel A Change Comin' On (Together Through Life, 2009)