It's the first I've heard of them. I like it, but I'm not sure it's the kind of music that will really find its way into my heavy rotation. I really like "Turn Smile Shift Repeat," though, so that one at least might.
I admit to being a huge fan of "California" - from WAY before The OC - and I really like "Anthem" although now I can't remember if that's on The Guest
or Phantom Planet
... honestly, I just really like the band, liked them better with Schwartzman, but I still bought all their subsequent albums. In fact, along with The Mooney Suzuki, Guster, and O.A.R, they are one of the bands whose albums I will likely always purchase (unless they really start to suck).
*Oh, and I bought the Chris Cornell album, Carry On
, yesterday. I really like his rendition of "Billie Jean" and I love (like really LOVE) his voice, ever since Soundgarden.