I was conceiving of this like the moment on the elevator in (500) Days of Summer where he hears her listening to The Smiths and assumes they are soulmates.
So what films would make me turn my head if I heard a woman touting them?
1. Lars and the Real Girl
2. The Hunchback of Notre Dame
3. Before Sunrise
4. CINECAST!ing Amal
5. 5 Centimeters Per Second
To more the original non-romantic implication I’d add:
1. Fish Tank
2. High Strung
3. Toys
4. Ruby Sparks