I only watched the Jimmy Stewart/Doris Day version, and I have to say that this be my least favorite Hitchcock film. I didn't find the story compelling. I felt that it went on way too long. I didn't like that the story had to fit in Doris Day's singing, which was annoying to begin with, and completely unnecessary. Like
Colleen, I found the sedation scene to be ridiculous. I really disliked this film to the point where it made me angry, which doesn't happen a lot in films.