I don't think it's a matter of criteria so much as whether the other material is good enough to eclipse the bothersome bits. In the Spider-Man films, it's not. The X-Men films just about break even. And Daredevil, for me, stays in the black, enjoyment-wise. Same with The Lord of the Rings movies. Elf boy skateboarding on his shield is way annoying, sure, but the overall battle at Helms Deep or whatever it's called is cool enough that it's not a huge deal.
pixote