What about just saving The Happening until next week. Otherwise a movie I would recommend is The Strangers. It is a really effective psychological horror movie. Also Capone liked it and Scott Smith raved about it.
Other Possibilities:
The Promotion
Reprise
The Foot Fist Way
Chronicles of Narnia
My Winipeg
Baghead
Quid Pro Quo
Scott Smith raved about it... where?
No interest in reviewing: Foot Fist, Narnia, Baghead, Strangers
Little interest in reviewing: Promotion
Not playing: Reprise, Quid Pro Quo
Want to see again but no need to discuss again: My Winnipeg