Outside of listening to the show, I don't follow film closely. So, it's not an unusual experience for me to be blindsided by an incredible movie "discovery"--The Squid and the Whale is an example--only to find out later that the move has a large, previously unknown to me, following.
I saw Funny Games at work on a movie channel. We thought it was a standard sado-thriller. I later heard Adam describing it as some kind of masterpiece. My mind was blown. If I'd heard Adam's description first, I've had hated it too. As I hadn't, I found it OK.
And as to the original question: No, that distinction belongs to Antichrist.