Ichabod possesses the film's highest points, though it also possesses far and away the lowest as well. Plus it's much more of a story than a film and is far more alienating than engrossing, so much so that I felt I'd be better off reading than watching. However, nostalgia obligates me to pick Sleepy Hollow.
Mr. Toad is, for all intents and purposes, much more consistent and engrossing, not to mention a better film, but I'm more inclined to say I prefer something that has already stood up to multiple repeat viewings than I am to take a film that I have now only just finished watching.