Speaking as a person who absolutely adored District 9 and considers it his favorite movie of the year, I really can't believe just how strong the arguments have been about it - especially since the debate really isn't whether it was good or bad, but whether it was great or just OK.
And I'm fairly sure Matty read my mind this week, as the very thought that went through my head once you guys finished your original District 9 discussion was "I bet they'll get a lot of negative feedback from District 9 fans even though they liked the movie. They should really create some sort of disclaimer." Matty's spiel was much better written than anything I could have come up with, though.