Listen - there are plenty of couples out there who would love a cheesecake of their own but can't make one, either because there is something wrong with their batter, their oven, or some other unfortunate circumstance. Giving up your cheesecake to one of these couples is always an option and there is no shame to it. Oftentimes it is the absolutely right thing to do.
After all, the worst that could happen is they eat it.