If the theme is guilty pleasure, I'm out. Once bitten...
Also: memory is a funny thing - I could have sworn there were many "meh" reactions to last year's guilty pleasure assignments (so really not good, as you would expect, but also not bad enough to be "so-bad-it's-good"), but I just re-read the thread, and most people found their films interesting/entertaining/pretty f**ing great. Huh.